Alexander Mirtchev Discusses the Worldwide Implications of the Rapidly Expanding State Intervention in Dealing With the Financial and Economic Crisis on Voice of America
Krull Corporation President Considers That Progressively Expanding State Intervention Is a Foregone Conclusion That Has Gone Past the Point of Debate, but Believes That the Criteria for Success Is, at a Minimum, Countering the Fear and Uncertainty About the Future, Boosting Market Confidence, Whilst Dealing With the Social Fallout of the Crisis, and, at the End of the Day, Bringing a New Level of Productivity, Competitiveness and Entrepreneurship, Combined With a Feasible Exit Strategy
| Source: Krull
WASHINGTON, DC--(Marketwire - February 19, 2009) - In an interview with Voice of America
television, Dr. Alexander
Mirtchev, a prominent economic policy practitioner and president of Krull Corporation, answered
questions about the challenges faced by the governments worldwide in
dealing with the financial crisis and the economic downturn. He offered his
comparative analysis of rescue options and current measures available to
the governments of the U.S. and other G-7 economies and the large emerging
markets such as Russia, Brazil and China.
"Even though the greatest focus has been on the U.S. and other developed
economies, the financial crisis and the concurrent steep economic downturn
that are mutually interlinked and reinforcing each other, are a global
phenomenon," indicated Mirtchev. He stressed that "virtually every
significant economic crisis gives rise to an expanded role of the state,
aimed at expediently dealing with the massive problems at hand. In this
case, the over-reliance of the general public (and some financial and
industrial institutions) on the government, exacerbated by the public
perception that there was a 'failure of the market,' and even of capitalism
itself, combined with the often demanding political calendar, shaped the
course of events. The 'elephant in the room' is the 'D' word -- depression,
as well as its price-tag, inevitable toll on society and its long-term
repercussions."
"Across the board, the measures attempt to integrate in a more or less
coherent way differing concepts for dealing with a wide range of pressing
issues -- insolvent banks, toxic assets, failing mortgages, problematic
securitization, outdated industry models, rising unemployment, etc., via
increased government or consumer spending, which amounts, predominantly, to
a consumption-driven recovery. The practical outcome from the interplay
between these concepts in the context of the global deleveraging is still
unclear, and would probably remain so for the foreseeable future, even
though the resulting measures should have a certain positive impact," said
Mirtchev.
"As ever-expanding government intervention in the markets is already a fact
of life, the issue from a mid and long-term perspective is how to work out
the best ways to utilize this intervention in order to boost productivity,
competitiveness and entrepreneurship, with a set time limit and transparent
exit strategy, and, simultaneously, to help and take care of the people
that have been most affected by the economic downturn and the financial
turmoil." In the short term, these measures should quickly lay the
foundation for increasing market confidence to combat the sentiment of
uncertainty and gloom among consumers, producers and investors worldwide.
In the long run, Mirtchev considers that the economic recovery package of
the U.S. government would need to include "quite creative measures," and,
most importantly, do their best to make the private sector part of the
process, in order to deal with the extraordinary economic situation and the
concomitant financial crisis.
"It becomes obvious that national and international financial systems need
to be fixed before a lasting economic recovery can start in earnest -- the
key seems to be to address the issues of the XXI century as opposed to
trying to 'put the genie back in the bottle.' Whatever solutions are put
forward for the international financial system, they would need to
recognize and utilize, rather than restrict, its newly developing nature,
and consider global, rather than rely on 'local' measures to deal with the
crisis. The measures could consider gradually building the elements of a
'global financial supermarket' of mass participation, based on the
technologies and infrastructure that is already in place, that empowers the
market players and individual consumers in a constructive way,
incentivizing rather than restricting, establishing clear, consistent and
transparent rules of the game, and, respectively, educating about the new
realities."
Taking as an example the auto industry, Mirtchev indicated that "faced with
a range of unfortunate choices, the U.S. government is confronted with the
question of how to assist the industry to update its business model for the
21st century, advance the technology, and become adequately productive and
competitive." Irrespective of the stated aims, "it is unlikely that the
government can efficiently manage car manufacturing or other industries,"
said Dr. Mirtchev. "Some of the questions to ask, in this context, are:
would the government intervention in the market be successful and what does
success mean; does the bail-out simply extend the agony of companies that
are 'too big to fail' and what is the price of failure; what are the
implications of government rewarding companies with unfair advantages and
de facto picking the winners; what is the best exit strategy? Clearly,
measures taken to assist one industry sector are occasionally fraught with
unforeseen consequences for other sectors, not to mention the looming
specter of protectionism."
The economic crisis has affected emerging markets and the rapidly
developing economies just as much as it did the developed economies. The
measures undertaken by the G-7 governments not only have a significant
impact, but also induce, to a certain extent, the shape of their own
response to the crisis. "There is no 'decoupling,'" according to Dr.
Mirtchev, "and the U.S. recovery measures and their effectiveness are
interdependent with the developments in the rest of the world."
"The economies and the financial systems of the developed and developing
countries are intertwined; the remedial measures would perforce a need to
be coordinated, even when some governments are more surgical and balanced
in their intervention than others." From Mirtchev's perspective, emerging
market countries, such as Russia, China, Brazil, etc., should be elevated
to the position of players with a much greater say in dealing with the
current crisis and bringing about the recovery, commensurate with their
contribution to global economic activity. "For example, economies, such as
Russia, would need to be engaged in the process of assisting global
economic recovery, and their role should be acceptable and beneficial for
all the players, and obviously, perceived as beneficial by Russia itself."
His view is that "not fully integrating the emerging markets in the
solution to the economic crisis may result in their becoming not only part
of the problem, but may lead to a significant fragmentation of the markets,
and even, by some accounts, a tendency towards a reversal of the
globalization process that would impede the recovery." Dr. Mirtchev
believes that not just their inclusion, but rather a new type of
coordination and cohesion of measures by governments in the emerging
markets and developed economies, are needed.
To view the interview, visit
http://www.voanews.com/russian/2008-12-20-voa7.cfm.
About Krull Corporation:
Krull Corporation is a Washington,
D.C.-based advisory and project management firm with expertise in dealing
with economic growth, industrial restructuring and modernization. Founded
by Dr. Alexander Mirtchev in 1992, Krull Corporation capitalizes on his
extensive professional experience in market developments and reforms and
focuses primarily on emerging market and rapidly developing economies. Over
the years, the firm has provided its clients with outstanding strategic
guidance and solutions. Combining a unique blend of global reach and
understanding of local markets, Krull is able to consistently produce
high quality results and returns.