On July 20, 2009 arbitrators Sven Papp and Erik Nerep made an award in AS Alta Foods and AS Luterma dispute by which AS Luterma has to return to AS Alta Foods 6 million euros (93,9 million kroons). AS Alta Foods had made a 6 million euro advanced payment to AS Luterma on the basis of contract concluded on 27th February 2008 in what parties agreed that all prerequisites for completion of transaction are fulfilled, completion of transaction is on 31st of March 2008, AS Alta Foods makes an advanced payment of 4 million euros (62,6 million kroons) on 29th of February 2008 to AS Luterma and on 3rd March 2008 advanced payment of 2 million euros (31,3 million kroons) and AS Luterma has the right to withdraw from advanced payments penalty fine and claim for the compensation of damage. AS Alta Foods made the previously agreed advanced payment of 2 million euros on 11th February 2008 behind schedule. On 31st March 2008 AS Alta Foods did not have the monetary funds to pay for shares and AS Luterma gave AS Alta Foods new exercise date, 30th May 2008. On 30th May 2008 AS Alta Foods did not have monetary funds to pay for shares and transaction was not completed. On 3rd June 2008 AS Alta Foods made a withdrawal from the contract of sale. According to contract of sale AS Alta Foods had the right to withdraw from the contract in situation of force majeure (market disruption, which is witnessed by experts in that field). According to arbitrators Sven Papp and Erik Nerep by 3rd June 2008 situation of force majeure, worldwide market disruption had been established, wherefore AS Alta Foods had the right to withdraw from the contract of sale. Arbitrators did not involve experts to the procedure. AS Alta Foods involved into procedure Gild Bankers to deliver opinion, from whom AS Alta Foods had partially loaned previously mentioned advance payment. AS Luterma involved into arbitral procedure internationally recognized experts Alfred Vanagsi and Hardo Pajula and based on reports of IMF and Bank of Estonia, by whom analysis market disruption had not occurred by 3rd June 2008. By named institutions and persons market disruption occurred on fall 2008, from the beginning of Lehman Brothers bankruptcy. Award requires AS Luterma to pay to AS Alta Foods 6 million euros and interest starting from 29th of August 2008 until returning of the advanced payment, also to pay arbitral fee in sum 216 600 euros and AS Alta Foods costs of legal assistance in sum 157 000 euros (7000 euros of which is for“expert opinion“of Gild Bankers). According to award AS Alta Foods has to pay AS Luterma interest for period of 1-6 July 2008 in accordance with LOA articles 113 (1) and 94 (1). Similar to arbitral award 13.07.2009 arbitrator professor Paul Varul maintained a dissenting opinion in final award. Dissenting opinion is unusual in arbitral tribunal and which to AS Luterma opinion proves that the award is problematical. In dissenting opinion Paul Varul finds amongs other that Gild Bankers can not be considered as independent experts. Award does not affect AS Luterma subsidiaries everyday economic activities. Allan Viirma Head of Legal Services Telephone 688 6600
Arbitration award
| Source: Luterma